Both encrypt with AES-256-GCM on the phone and need no account. Obscura opens each vault with a password that can't be recovered, publishes its encryption code, and also runs on Android. Vaultern opens with a pattern or six-digit PIN, gives every vault a 12-word recovery phrase, and backs it up to your own iCloud by default.
Vaultern vs Obscura at a glance
| Obscura | Vaultern | |
|---|---|---|
| Account needed | None | None |
| How it opens | A password per vault; Face ID or Touch ID | A pattern on a 5 by 5 grid, or a six-digit PIN |
| Encryption | AES-256-GCM; key from PBKDF2, 600,000 rounds | AES-256-GCM; key from Argon2id and a device secret |
| Backup | Encrypted export file; iOS iCloud Backup | Its own encrypted iCloud backup, on by default |
| Decoy or second vault | A second vault, usable as a decoy, with Pro | Decoy vault free; Emergency pattern with Pro |
| Private camera | Quick camera; shots never reach Photos | Shots go into the vault, metadata removed |
| Price model | Free; Pro monthly, yearly or once | Free, with a Pro plan |
| Data collected | Label: Data Not Collected | No analytics; nothing stored with us |
| Platforms | iPhone, iPad, Android | iPhone, iPad |
What Obscura does well
Obscura names its cipher and key derivation and publishes its encryption code on GitHub. It needs no internet connection, and its App Store label says it collects no data. Its document tools read the text of scanned papers on the phone for search, flag expiry dates, and can share a redacted, watermarked Safe Copy of an ID. It also runs on Android, and Pro is sold once as well as by subscription.
How Vaultern is different
- A way back in. Obscura deliberately offers no reset: if the password is forgotten, so is that vault. Vaultern shows you a recovery phrase of 12 random words when you create each vault, and that phrase opens the vault if you forget the pattern. Lose the pattern and the phrase together, and that vault is gone too.
- Backup that runs by itself. Obscura leaves backup to your phone’s iCloud Backup or an export file you move yourself, and vaults don’t sync between devices. Vaultern copies each vault to your own iCloud, encrypted on the phone first, unless you turn backup off. With Pro, a vault can also sync between iPhone and iPad.
- A copy is useless elsewhere. Obscura slows guessing with 600,000 rounds of PBKDF2. Vaultern’s key needs your pattern and a secret sealed by the phone’s Secure Enclave, which never leaves the phone and is never in a backup, so a copy can’t be guessed open on another computer. See how long guessing takes.
- Draw instead of type. Your lock is a shape: six or more dots joined on a 5 by 5 grid, or a six-digit PIN. Face ID can stand in front but is never part of the key.
- The decoy is free. Obscura’s free version holds one vault, so a decoy needs Pro. Vaultern’s decoy vault is offered during setup and costs nothing. With Pro, an Emergency pattern, for when someone forces you to open the app, shows one vault and clears the rest off the phone; each comes back from iCloud with its recovery phrase.
Which one should you choose?
Pick Obscura if you also use Android or want to read the encryption code yourself. Pick Vaultern if you would rather draw a pattern than type a password, want a recovery phrase for the day you forget it, and want backup to happen without you.
Sources
- App Store, Obscura: Encrypted Photo Vault by Orlio Inc: description, in-app purchases and privacy label.
- Orlio Inc, obscura-vault.com.
- Orlio Inc, Obscura privacy policy.
- Orlio Inc, Obscura security architecture.
- App Store, Obscura — Pro Camera, a different app.
Questions
Is Obscura a camera app or a photo vault?
Two different apps share the name. This page compares Obscura: Encrypted Photo Vault, by Orlio Inc, a vault for photos, videos and documents. Obscura — Pro Camera is a camera app whose photos go to your photo library.
Is Obscura safe?
Orlio Inc encrypts every photo, video and document on the device with AES-256-GCM and publishes the code that does it on GitHub. The app works without an internet connection, and its App Store label says the developer collects no data.
Is Obscura free?
The free version holds one vault with a capped number of items. Obscura Pro removes both caps, by monthly or yearly subscription or with a one-time Lifetime purchase.
Does Obscura back up my photos?
It has no cloud of its own. The vault is part of your iPhone's iCloud Backup by default, already encrypted, and a whole vault can be exported as one encrypted .obscura file that you store where you choose.
What if I forget my Obscura password?
Then that vault stays locked for good. Obscura offers no reset or recovery on purpose, and its developer advises writing the password down somewhere safe.
What is a good alternative to Obscura?
Vaultern, if you want a way back in and a backup that runs on its own. Each vault opens with a drawn pattern or a six-digit PIN, has its own 12-word recovery phrase, and is copied to your own iCloud, encrypted on the phone first.